Let’s Talk Bookish: what do you look for in a review?

It’s been quite a while, but I’m back: several tests done, two to go. Anyways, I am super excited to get back on track and why not start with Let’s Talk Bookish – especially, when I suggested the topic. I’m super interested what all the other came up with, so if you’ve participated: comment! Let’s Talk Bookish is as always hosted by  Dani @ Literary Lion and Rukky @ Eternity Books!

#1 A brief summary of the book

I find it EXTREMELY helpful when there is a small summary at the very start of the review – one to three sentences, that is all I am looking for. And that has a very smart (at least for me) reason: I immediately know whether I’d be totally thrown off by the plot because it’s not at all what I like to read – or if I should continue reading and figure out whether I’d like to give the book a chance!

#2 Some additional information on the book

I love it when there’s another paragraph/list under the summary where you can check out the genre of the book as well as the pages, the author’s name and the publication date! And, if the blogger likes it, the star-rating.

#3 Favorite and least favorite aspects explained

A clear structure: that is what I am looking for. And explaining what you loved and which aspects you disliked (and also actually saying why and not simply stating facts) is super helpful to give the an impression of the book. Also, when I’ve already read the book and want to check out what other people thought, it’s easy to compare your thoughts and feelings on the book!

#4 Structuring your paragraphs: plot, characters, writing and atmosphere

This is my absolute favorite part of writing a review: structuring the paragraphs so that readers are able to follow and know that this paragraph will only focus on one aspect, while the other talks about something else. It’s helpful in order not to confuse people and I love that!

What I don’t need: a star-rating!

I mean, it’s never bad to have another impression besides a text and see how many stars the blogger rated this book. But often it’s super confusing because the writing and the star-rating don’t always correlate the way I’d expected them. Some people liked everything about a book except the characters and then their result is 3/5 while others rate it 4/5 – and that is simply because everyone has different priorities and favorite aspects that weigh differently.

Moreover, I often struggle with rating books myself because I am unsure how grave that one dislike should be seen in my star-rating – was it a 5/5 or does that small detail make it a 4.5/5. That makes a difference!

That’s it – everything I look for in a review! Tell me: what do you look for, do we have the same priorities? Comment! And happy reading and let’s hope I have some more blogging time in the future!

Author: Blogger Books

I'm a huge fan of Draco Malfoy, I love scones and tea time, I don't like horror movies and obviously I'm a huge book nerd.

8 thoughts on “Let’s Talk Bookish: what do you look for in a review?”

    1. NOOOO! And the summary isn’t the most important thing, easily google-able! And I love it when people are passionate, that makes me want to read the book as well and also know that a person is sincere about what they’re saying!
      Happy reading!

      Like

  1. I also often struggle with deciding on a star rating! For me the star rating is definitely not the main thing I look for in a review. I think that it’s nice to have it, but reading someone’s thoughts on different aspects like the plot and the writing, or seeing what they did or did not like is much more important to me. This is a really great post Jane!

    Like

    1. Thanks so much! And I also try to do that! But it’s sometimes difficult not to let those 2 or one star ratings get in my head… Because then I’m like “should I really spend 10$ on a book that was reviewed so negatively?”
      happy reading!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s